WhitelistVideo
Start Free
Frustrated parent looking at poor Securly Home app reviews on phone
Competitor Alternatives

Securly Home App Alternatives: Better Options After the 1.3-Star Disaster

Securly Home has a 1.3-star rating with constant crashes and no YouTube channel whitelisting. Parents deserve better. Here are reliable alternatives that actually work.

Sarah Mitchell

Sarah Mitchell

Consumer Technology Analyst

Dec 15, 2025
Updated May 22, 2026✓ Current
7 min read
Securly HomeSecurly AlternativeParental Control AppsApp ReviewsYouTube Filtering

TL;DR: Securly Home is sitting at a 1.3-star rating for a reason: it crashes, kills batteries, and kids can bypass it in minutes. It also lacks the YouTube channel whitelisting that makes their school version so popular. If you're tired of the bugs, look at WhitelistVideo for YouTube control (4.7 stars), Qustodio for full monitoring, or Apple’s built-in Screen Time for a free option.


The Securly Home Disaster

Most parents know Securly from their kid's school. Their enterprise software is actually pretty solid—it’s sophisticated and gives schools great control over things like YouTube channel whitelisting.

But the consumer version, Securly Home, is a different story.

The ratings are brutal:

  • Google Play Store: 1.3 stars
  • Apple App Store: 2.1 stars
  • Trustpilot: 2.8 stars

These aren't just a few disgruntled users or "growing pains." The app has been around for years and it’s still barely functional. Parents expected school-level quality and ended up with a buggy app that doesn't deliver on its basic promises.

30-Second Check

Will WhitelistVideo Work for Your Child?

Answer 4 quick questions about your child's devices and age — get a personalized setup recommendation.

10,000+ families · Free
Check If It WorksPersonalized result in 30 seconds

What's Wrong with Securly Home?

1. It crashes constantly

"App crashes every single day. I have to reinstall it weekly just to get it working again. My son figured out if he just waits, it'll crash on its own and stop filtering." - Google Play Review

Technical stability is the biggest complaint. Parents report "Service unavailable" errors and a dashboard that simply refuses to update or sync with their child's device. If the app isn't running, the filtering isn't working.

2. It kills the battery

"This app drains my daughter's phone battery in 3-4 hours. She can't make it through a school day without charging." - Google Play Review

Securly Home uses a VPN to route traffic through its filters. Because the app is poorly optimized, that VPN connection stays "active" in a way that drains a phone's battery in just a few hours.

3. The "School Device" bait-and-switch

Many of the features Securly advertises only work if the device is managed by a school. If you install this on a personal iPad or phone at home, you get a watered-down version. Most parents don't realize this until after they've paid the subscription fee.

4. No YouTube Channel Whitelisting

This is the biggest letdown. In the school version of Securly, teachers can approve specific channels and block the rest. Securly Home doesn't do this. You’re stuck with three bad options: block all of YouTube, allow all of it, or use a "restricted mode" that misses a huge amount of inappropriate content.

5. Kids bypass it in minutes

If your child is even slightly tech-savvy, Securly Home won't stop them. Common bypasses include:

  • Free VPNs: Kids download a free VPN to route around Securly's filter.
  • Incognito Mode: Private browsing often slips right past the browser-level filtering.
  • Switching Browsers: If Chrome is filtered, they just download Firefox or Edge.
  • Cellular Data: The filtering often fails the moment the child leaves the home WiFi.

6. Support is non-existent

When things go wrong, don't expect help. Parents report waiting weeks for ticket responses or sitting on hold for nearly an hour only to get a generic, unhelpful answer.

Why Is Securly Home So Bad?

Different Products, Same Name

It’s a classic case of a company focusing on where the money is. Securly makes its real profit from multi-million dollar school contracts. The home app feels like a side project that’s been left to rot.

Feature Securly (School) Securly Home
YouTube Channel Whitelisting ✅ Yes ❌ No
Filtering Reliability ✅ Very High ❌ Poor
Bypass Resistance ✅ High ❌ Low
User Rating 4.5+ stars 1.3 stars
Price per User ~$10-30/year $83.88/year

Best Securly Home Alternatives (2026)

1. WhitelistVideo (Best for YouTube Control)

If your main reason for using Securly was to manage YouTube, this is the better choice. It actually does what Securly Home promises: you pick the channels your kids can watch, and everything else is blocked. It’s also way more stable (4.7 stars) and doesn't kill the battery because it doesn't use the same clunky VPN tech.

Pros:

  • True channel whitelisting (the only consumer app that has it)
  • Free tier available
  • Works on cellular and WiFi
  • Cheaper than Securly ($4.99/month)

Cons: Only filters YouTube, not the whole web.

Best for: Parents who specifically want to fix the "YouTube problem."

Try WhitelistVideo Free →

2. Qustodio (Best for Full Monitoring)

If you need to monitor everything—texts, location, and web history—Qustodio is the standard. It’s not perfect, but it doesn't crash every ten minutes. It’s better at detecting VPNs and has much more reliable activity reports.

Pros: Works on everything (iOS, Android, PC, Mac) and includes location tracking.

Cons: No YouTube channel whitelisting and it's more expensive ($137.95/year).

Best for: Parents who want a "command center" for all device activity.

3. Circle (Best for Home WiFi)

Circle is a hardware box that plugs into your router. Because it's a physical device, it doesn't "crash" like an app and it doesn't drain your kid's battery. It filters every single device on your home WiFi automatically.

Pros: Very reliable and easy to set up. Great for "pausing" the internet for dinner.

Cons: Doesn't work when the kid is on cellular data (unless you pay for their extra mobile app) and requires a $129 hardware purchase.

4. Apple Screen Time (Best Free Option)

If you have an iPhone family, don't overlook the built-in tools. Screen Time is free, it’s built into the operating system (so it can't be uninstalled), and it doesn't drain the battery.

Pros: Free, reliable, and impossible for a kid to delete.

Cons: Only works on Apple devices. No YouTube channel whitelisting.

Question 1 of 425%

What devices does your child use for YouTube?

iPhone or Android phone
iPad or Android tablet
Chromebook or laptop
Android TV or Google TV
3 more questions reveal your personalized setupCheck If It Works

Comparison: Securly Home vs. The Competition

Feature Securly Home WhitelistVideo Qustodio Circle
User Rating 1.3 stars ⭐ 4.7 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.0 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.2 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐
YouTube Whitelisting ❌ No ✅ Yes ❌ No ❌ No
Reliability ❌ Constant crashes ✅ Stable ✅ Stable ✅ Hardware-based
Battery Drain ❌ Severe ✅ Minimal ⚠️ Moderate ✅ None
Monthly Cost $6.99 $4.99 $11.49 $9.95 + hardware

How to Switch and Cancel

Don't just delete the app—you need to make sure the subscription is dead and the hidden profiles are gone.

  1. Set up your new service first. Test it for a week to make sure you like it before cutting ties with Securly.
  2. Delete the VPN profile. On iPhones, go to Settings → General → VPN and delete the Securly profile. If you don't do this, the phone might still try to route traffic through their broken servers.
  3. Cancel the subscription. Do this through the Securly dashboard or your app store settings.
  4. Ask for a refund. If the app never worked for you, contact their support. Many parents have successfully argued for a refund by citing technical failures.

The Bottom Line

A 1.3-star rating is hard to achieve. It takes a special level of technical failure and poor support to get there. You aren't imagining the bugs, and you aren't "doing it wrong"—the app just isn't good.

If you're paying $80+ a year for something that your kid can bypass with a free VPN, it’s time to move on. If YouTube is your main concern, WhitelistVideo actually provides the control Securly Home only pretends to have. If you need a full suite of tools, Qustodio or Circle are much more dependable.

Stop fighting with an app that doesn't work. Switch to something that actually keeps your kids safe.

Try WhitelistVideo Free – Get the YouTube Control Securly Home Promises But Doesn't Deliver →

Looking for Better YouTube Control?

Purpose-built for YouTube protection with channel whitelisting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Securly Home has a 1.3-star rating on Google Play and 2.1 stars on the App Store due to constant technical issues: app crashes, battery drain, features that only work on school-managed devices, ineffective filtering, and easy bypasses. Parents report paying for a service that doesn't deliver on its promises and has unresponsive customer support.

No. Despite Securly's enterprise school product offering excellent YouTube channel whitelisting, Securly Home does not include this feature. Securly Home relies on basic web category filtering that either blocks all of YouTube or allows it with minimal filtering. There's no channel-level control for home users.

Yes. Parents consistently report that children bypass Securly Home using VPN apps, incognito mode, different browsers, or simply turning off WiFi to use cellular data. Securly Home's filtering is browser-based and doesn't work reliably on cellular connections, making it easy to circumvent.

WhitelistVideo is the best alternative for parents specifically wanting YouTube control. Unlike Securly Home's category-based filtering, WhitelistVideo offers true YouTube channel whitelisting—the same feature available in Securly's enterprise product. It's bypass-proof, works on all connections, and has a 4.7-star rating.

Read in other languages:

Share this article

Published: December 15, 2025 • Last Updated: May 22, 2026

Sarah Mitchell

About Sarah Mitchell

Consumer Technology Analyst

Sarah Mitchell is an independent technology analyst specializing in family safety software evaluation. She holds a B.S. in Information Systems from MIT and spent seven years at Gartner as a research analyst covering enterprise endpoint security. Sarah has conducted hands-on testing of over 80 parental control applications, publishing methodology-driven reviews in The New York Times Wirecutter, CNET, and PCMag. She developed the "Bypass Resistance Index," an industry-cited framework for evaluating parental control robustness. As a mother of three, she brings personal experience to her professional analysis. She is a guest contributor at WhitelistVideo.

You Might Also Like

Curious what Google knows about us?

Add WhitelistVideo as a trusted source on Google — get instant context on how families keep kids safe on YouTube.

Ask Google about WhitelistVideo
AI-Powered Help

Get Instant Answers with AI

Ask any AI assistant about YouTube parental controls, setup guides, or troubleshooting.

ChatGPT

ChatGPT

Perplexity

Perplexity

Claude

Claude

Gemini

Gemini

Click 'Ask' to open the AI with your question pre-filled. For Gemini, copy the question first.

we're featured in