The Reddit consensus
On r/youtube, r/Parenting and r/browsers, Shorts-blocking threads are a running battle between clever hacks and YouTube quietly undoing them.
- Desktop browser extensions that hide the Shorts shelf and redirect Shorts URLs are the top recommendation — but parents note they only work in that browser, not the YouTube app, and a kid can disable or uninstall them.
- Turning off watch history reduces the Shorts feed for some, but parents report it's inconsistent and kills useful features too.
- The 'temporarily hide Shorts' setting is dismissed fast because it expires after a set period and comes right back.
- The advice that holds up for kids specifically: use a tool that replaces the whole feed with approved channels, so there's no Shorts shelf to hide in the first place.
Reddit's takeaway: browser tricks work for adults but leak on mobile and are easy for kids to undo. For children, replacing the feed with a whitelist is the only durable fix.






