The Reddit consensus
On r/Parenting, r/GoogleFamilyLink and r/youtube, supervised-account threads follow a familiar arc: relief at escaping YouTube Kids, then frustration within weeks.
- Parents report the 'Older kids' tier letting through gaming drama, brain-rot compilations and borderline content that is 'technically fine for 9+' but nothing they'd have picked — the tier is a fence around millions of videos, not a curated list.
- The block-a-channel feature gets described as whack-a-mole: you can only block after your child has already watched, and the algorithm keeps serving new channels from the same pool.
- A recurring complaint is about Shorts: the daily Shorts feed limit can be set to zero, but it follows the signed-in supervised account, so a signed-out browser, another profile or another account still shows Shorts.
- The most-upvoted alternative in these threads: a whitelist on the regular YouTube app, so the child keeps 'real' YouTube but only sees channels a parent approved in advance.
Reddit's takeaway: supervised accounts filter by category when parents want to choose by channel. A whitelist on the real app — which is what WhitelistVideo provides — closes that gap.




